I think somebody on here tried them,  Wondered how they got on??  I really like the idea of using csj foods but am still looking for the right one...

I'm getting to the end of a bag of Herbie Rings (so about 2 months)

The dogs love them and they smell lovely but personally I think the dogs looked better and had better muscle tone/weight on That'll Do! so next order I will be going back to that.  I did have the pup on Herbie Rings mixed with Little Champ (mum was on this while pregnant and feeding pups) too and she was growing nicely, but turned into a very hyper lunatic so for the last few days she's back on JWB puppy (turkey) and already she's calmer

After winning a half sack of Burns 2 weeks ago (well the pup did lol), I've mixed the end of the Little Champ and the end of the Herbie Rings with an equal amount of Burns and will be feeding that 'till it's gone. Waste not want not and all that   I may have to add a little oil/fat tho to keep the fat ratio up   but I've made sure that the protein level matches That'll Do! so it shouldn't cause too much change in them

After that it's back to That'll Do! for both adults and pup - They had better coats/weight/muscle/energy and it's cheaper too now that's what I call a win-win situation

Forgot to add,

If it's just a case of which one to buy, as opposed to allergies, try to match the protein and fat levels to whatever food your dog has done really well on and work from there    I tried to match up to the protein and fat etc. levels in Gusto as my dogs have done really well on that but I prefer to have a more detailed list of ingredients